Skip links

5 Blockers for blockchain in commodities*

1. Legal certainty

Much discussion has been had on the legality of digital versions of existing paper such as bills of lading and warehouse receipts. As an example, very few jurisdictions globally fully support the complete dematerialisation of paper. This is one of the reasons that the leading market infrastructure organisations employ a depository model, so in the case of going to law, paper certificates can be produced as evidence of ownership or rights entitlement.

When commodities market participants such as traders and financers look at large commodity based deals, the values can extend to millions of dollars, meaning that legal certainty is not something taken lightly.

Existing market infrastructure players have spent many millions obtaining legal opinion on structures and for different jurisdictions. Yet many institutions are still uncertain of the legal status of blockchain-based records

Commodities software
Commodities software

2. Physical nature of the underlying

Because the underlying product is so physical in nature, linking a digital/blockchain record to a large stack of metal or a bulk pile of cocoa beans is inherently tricky. IoT offers some potential solutions but work is still needed to ensure that, at the point of entry on to a ledger, the goods are accurately depicted (a form of consensus…).

It’s also true that the goods in question must remain in a known state (i.e. quantity and quality) while they are represented by ledger records. Agricultural commodities degrade over time, oil products change their physical properties and volumes and warehouses have been known to move metals around in warehouses – how is this monitored in digital terms?

3. Market desire for opacity

The physical commodities world thrives on information advantage.

Simply knowing where certain commodities are held or are due to be loaded, or who owns them, can give rise to significant commercial advantage. Platforms which potentially offer fuller transparency are bound not to be popular.

Commodities software
Commodities software

4. First mover jitters

Early adoption is often perceived as an advantage, especially when it comes to technology.

However, the physical commodities world is often perceived as a more traditional market, in which participants prefer to follow after the pioneers, rather than make the investment only to be overtaken once the flaws and challenges have been solved

5. Lack of regulatory drive

The physical side of the commodities sector is largely unregulated at the moment. Regulation and regulatory reporting in particular has been one of the major drivers for processes going digital.

Without this pressure from a regulatory perspective, participants have less motivation to invest in technology like blockchain which in theory provides increased transparency, more safeguarding and easier (mandatory) reporting.

Commodities software

You may have noticed that nothing above mentions the actual technology. That’s because the technology, whilst not completely established or mature yet, will undoubtedly get there.

Recent reports of high performance blockchains and the huge investments that leading technology companies are making will deliver the performance, interoperability and standards that are required.

The wide range of companies, both fintech and traditional, that are dedicating resource and effort to proofs of concept, trials and experiments will lead to breakthroughs and real progress. Technology is not the issue, and those that think it is are missing the point.

*blockers for now, at least

 

Your feedback and additional thoughts are welcome

Opinions

  1. Post comment

    the trend is to just date asian women

    Get reddit premiumA Hapa group for multiracial Eurasians, Blasians, Quapas, Hfus (), Hnxu (), Luk khrueng (), Honhyeol (), Amerasians (e lai); That welcomes all type mixed race part Asian Pacific Islanders.

    We have also an anti racist safe space to empower Hapas who grow chinese women up in interracial families that suffer from White Patriarchy and internalized white supremacy

    No posting comments on linked pages. Archived links are most popular

    No posting of information /social media. (including your own)

    No getting out of hand or personal attacks, Even for verified Hapa users this will result in temporary bans that will increase in severity for repeated offenses, Or permanent bans according to the situation.

    Non Hapas who make posts that are not on the main topic of Hapa people will be banned

    New Users must enter their racial mix as part of the flair

    Visitors from Alt Right Extremist subreddits are granted non hateful free speech to debate their points of views here. nonetheless they must be held accountable transparent. prospects posting in racist, white wines nationalist, Misogynist subreddits in particular r/the_donald, R/CringeAnarchy, R/TheRedPill should flair as such. Failure to comply will are a catalyst for banning. I am mixed race on my own, Half Persian/half a language like german.

    I have always seen as white, I was raised in Texas, But i am not saying a blond/blue eyed guy unlike my dad.

    I have friends may well be hapas, I never considered that to be anything amazing or even a negative quality (Just learned there was even a term a few days ago). One of my friends is equally as successful as me with women, I dated his sister for a bit and if she is the lady version of him, I can interpret him being found attractive.

    If theres some sort of white worship going on in the asian female community, Shouldn everyone (hapas) Be slaying right now? my friend dated a hapa girl who was a knockout also. you should date other hapas?

    In a setting of folks who are fully white, I would infer myself as mixed persian. In a setting of those unfortunates who are fully persian, I would talk about myself as mixed white. Context problems.

    I don actually have a problem with that. I also don believe it true; with me people have fixated more on cultural identification and assimilation than pure racial makeup. Also the non white worshiping hapa girls also opt for full Asian guys. could possibly hapa youtuber and she said she prefers full Asian guys over hapa guys and white guys.

    Permalink

Join the Discussion